more fair or fairer

Pretty Owners

3 min read

·

27-12-2024

3

0

Share

The Enduring Debate: "More Fair" vs. "Fairer"

The seemingly simple choice between "more fair" and "fairer" has sparked debate among grammar enthusiasts and language purists for years. While both options aim to express a higher degree of fairness, their usage often depends on nuanced considerations of style, formality, and the specific context. This article delves into the intricacies of this grammatical conundrum, exploring the arguments for each choice and offering guidance on when to use each.

Understanding the Grammar:

Both "fair" and "fairer" are adjectives describing something equitable, just, or impartial. "Fair" is the base adjective, while "fairer" is its comparative form, indicating a greater degree of fairness than something else. "More fair," on the other hand, utilizes the adverb "more" to modify the adjective "fair," achieving the same comparative function. So, the core question becomes: are both grammatically correct, and if so, what are the subtle differences that dictate their appropriate use?

The Case for "Fairer":

Many style guides and grammar experts advocate for "fairer" as the more elegant and concise option. This is because it leverages the inherent comparative structure of the English language, directly modifying the adjective itself. Using "fairer" feels more natural and flows better in most sentences. For example:

• "Fairer" example: "The new policy is fairer to low-income families."

This sentence is clear, concise, and grammatically sound. The use of "fairer" directly conveys the comparative aspect without any unnecessary words.

The Case for "More Fair":

The argument for "more fair" often centers on its applicability with certain adjectives. While "fairer" works perfectly well in most cases, some argue that "more fair" sounds more natural when dealing with adjectives that don't easily lend themselves to the "-er" suffix. However, this is a matter of stylistic preference rather than strict grammatical rule.

• "More Fair" Example (arguable): "This system is more fair than the previous one."

While grammatically correct, some might argue that "This system is fairer than the previous one" sounds more natural and refined. The difference is often subtle.

Analyzing Specific Contexts:

Let's examine different contexts to further illustrate the nuances:

• Formal Writing: In formal writing, such as academic papers or legal documents, "fairer" is generally preferred for its conciseness and elegance. Its straightforward comparative form aligns with the formality of such contexts.

• Informal Writing: In informal settings, the choice becomes more flexible. "More fair" might be used more frequently in casual conversation or less formal writing, primarily due to its greater familiarity. However, even in informal settings, "fairer" still maintains its grammatical correctness and often sounds more polished.

• Comparative Emphasis: If you want to emphasize the degree of difference in fairness, either construction could work. However, using "much fairer" or "considerably more fair" could provide stronger emphasis.

• Adjectives with Irregular Comparatives: Some adjectives have irregular comparative forms (e.g., good/better, bad/worse). With such adjectives, using "more" is essential. However, "fair" does not fall into this category.

Practical Examples and Further Clarification:

Let's compare direct examples to highlight the subtleties:

• Scenario 1: Comparing two policies: "The revised policy is fairer to all stakeholders." (Preferred)
• Scenario 2: Discussing a change in treatment: "The judge's decision resulted in a more fair outcome." (Acceptable, but "fairer" might be slightly preferred in this context.)
• Scenario 3: Highlighting a significant improvement: "The new system is considerably more fair than its predecessor." (Emphasis is correctly placed)
• Scenario 4: Casual conversation: "This deal seems more fair to me now." (Acceptable in informal settings.)

Beyond the Grammar: Semantic Considerations

Beyond the grammatical correctness, consider the semantic implications. While both phrases aim for similar meaning, "more fair" might subtly imply a higher degree of measured fairness, while "fairer" simply indicates a greater amount of fairness in comparison. This difference, however, is very minor and often inconsequential in practice.

Conclusion:

In conclusion, while both "more fair" and "fairer" are grammatically acceptable, "fairer" is generally preferred for its conciseness, elegance, and adherence to standard grammatical practice. However, "more fair" remains acceptable, especially in informal contexts or when emphasizing a quantifiable increase in fairness. Ultimately, the best choice depends on context, style, and the writer's desired level of formality. Choosing "fairer" demonstrates a more refined command of English grammar, but using "more fair" does not inherently constitute an error. The key is consistency and clarity in your writing, whatever option you choose. Always prioritize the choice that best serves your intended audience and the overall tone of your work.